A Lost Lady

I was so happy to read Willa Cather this week – to be back in the West, in the beautiful landscape of Nebraska, in the small railroad towns and among the pioneers who are rough yet cultured in their own way. I always feel that reading Cather is the closest I get to reading about my own heritage in a novel (other than reading Westerns, I suppose) as my mom’s family were all pioneers, settling in Utah, Nevada, New Mexico and, eventually, Arizona. Cather’s settings and characters are so familiar to me.

A Lost Lady is set in Sweet Water, a small town in Nebraska that is on the rail line between Omaha and Denver. Mrs. Forrester is a beautiful, mysterious, refined woman who lives with her wealthy husband in a big, lovely house on the outskirts of town. She’s vibrant and flirtatious – what is often called a man’s woman. Young Niel Herbert falls under her spell rather early in his life and as he grows up we see Mrs. Forrester from his perspective – from near perfection to the clear-eyed disappointment we sometimes develop in the cherished adults of our youth. But always he protects her, helps her, forgives her, until she finally puts her faith in the wrong person and his respect for her cracks.

This is a fascinating portrait of a woman who, like the West, is in transition. Though Niel longs for her to remain steady in her charms and perfection, Mrs. Forrester needs to change as the world changes. It is upsetting to all of the men around her and ultimately leads her to break with the people who want to maintain tradition and stability. It is a convincing character study and a classic portrait of frontier life on the verge of vanishing.

A short novel at just 150 pages, but a powerful one. Willa Cather’s writing is sensational, especially as it is not showy, but subtle and quiet.

Thank you to Ali for hosting this week. I’m now motivated to read the rest of Cather’s novels.


  1. Lory @ Emerald City Book Review

    I enjoyed this one this week too. I am now in the middle of Shadows on the Rock, which I love even more (not about the West though — it’s set in 17th century Quebec).

  2. I love your thoughts on A Lost Lady, my review just came out this morning too. Now reading Shadows on the Rock have really enjoyed the reading week.

  3. piningforthewest

    I had meant to take part in the reading week but somehow it got away from me, the time is just passing too quickly. I haven’t read A Lost Lady yet and I think that’ll be my next Cather read. Thanks!

  4. I’ve had A Lost Lady on my Goodreads To Read list for a while. I’m even more interested to read it after reading your review. The description of Mrs. Forrester reminds me of certain aspects of an Edith Wharton heroine. I’ll be interested to see how that develops in a Western setting.

%d bloggers like this: