After reading Excellent Women I knew, just knew, that I had to read more of Pym’s novels. Jane and Prudence was the second one I read and I did love it, not as much as Excellent Women, but love it I did.

The two women of the title are old friends from Oxford. Jane is older and was Prudence’s tutor at college. She’s now married to a vicar and still has a fondness for her specialty, 18th century poetry.  Prudence is 29, single, works at a mysterious office in London, has a crush on her boss and is undeniably beautiful and tries to be glamorous. The two women’s lives intersect again when Jane decides to set Prudence up with her new neighbor Fabian Driver, a handsome widower.

The story is told with Pym’s signature wit and gentle handling of the absurdity of human beings and their quirks. Jane is not your typical vicar’s wife; she can’ t cook to save her life, her housekeeping skills are extremely below average and she always looks a mess. Yet she is very interested in people and likes the interaction with them that a vicar’s wife is privileged with. She feels her inadequacies keenly, but after 20 years of marriage she has learned not to let her lack of traditional skills bother her.

Prudence is an altogether different sort of woman. She relishes the domestic arts, dresses beautifully and is always well turned out, has a comfortable and inviting home and is a good cook. She’s not completely unhappy about being unmarried as she enjoys being courted and spoiled by men. She and Jane seem like a mismatched pair of friends, but something in each of them complements the other and they find each others’ lives fascinating.

The question of women’s roles are the foundation of this novel. I love how Pym gives the vicar’s wife absolutely no domestic talents yet the aging single woman is a wonderful homemaker and really isn’t all that interested in entering into a conventional union. It is all cloaked in Pym’s lovely, light humor and great characterizations.

The more I read Pym, the more I am impressed. Achieving such a buoyant style with complex undertones is much harder than it looks. I really admire her writing and I look forward to reading many more (if not all) of her novels.


  1. Lovely review. I think I may have to make this my next Pym! My first few encounters with her were less than successful but I loved Excellent Women and really want to follow that up with another book I can enjoy. This sounds like it might be the perfect choice!

    • Thanks, Claire! I think it is a worthy follow-up to Excellent Women, better than Some Tame Gazelle (which I am reading right now).

  2. I was lucky enough to find a copy of Excellent Women at Half Price Books this weekend, and I’m so looking forward to reading it. I’ll keep an eye out for this one as well.

  3. I loved Jane and Prudence, and if you think Excellent Women is better I am definitely inspired to pick it up soon.

    • I do think EW is better! It is more humorous and has a smashing main character in Mildred Lathbury – you can’t help but love her.

  4. I received Excellent Women as a birthday gift last year, maybe I should drop hints for Jane & Prudence for this year!

    • I can’t think of a better birthday gift than a Barbara Pym novel! I received 5 of her novels for my own birthday back in April and was thrilled.

  5. This was highly recommended to me by a friend. Your review makes me even more eager to read it!

  6. You make me want to explore this author…

  7. It’s a nice post.

%d bloggers like this: